Montgomery County Council Votes to Keep Dickerson Incinerator Open
________
Updated November 12, 2026
The Montgomery County Council voted 6-5 at its November 10 session to continue operation of the Dickerson Incinerator.
Voting to keep the incinerator open were Council president Natali Fani-Gonzalez, and Councilmembers Dawn Luedtke, Shebra Evans, Sidney Katz, Kate Stewart, and Evan Glass.
Voting for closure were Councilmembers Marilyn Balcombe, Will Jawando, Andrew Friedson, Laurie-Anne Sayles, and Kristin Mink.
So where does this leave SCA, our supporters, and our partners who have long advocated for shutting down the incinerator?
The Council voted on a resolution to invest in the incinerator and keep it running for the long-term.
They also voted to pursue composting and advanced waste processing. A resolution, however, is non-binding. It recommends a course to the County Council, but not implementation. The Council must now procure bids to refurbish the incinerator with the highest protective standards that technology can provide.
New bids must also be procured now for hauling the incinerator’s toxic ash to a new site with technology that can protect the receiving community. The ash currently is dumped in an open landfill from which the ash can blow into a densely populated majority-Black community next to the landfill site in Montrose, Virginia.
These two initiatives will be difficult to implement and may well prove to be prohibitively expensive.
The County Council resolution also calls for a county-wide food scrap composting strategy. However, by choosing to keep incinerating our trash, they will need to find an alternate site to the Dickerson Yard Trim Facility. This choice will cost double the price and take three times as long to implement as one sited at the existing Dickerson composting facility.
Finally, the resolution calls for implementing advanced waste processing. This is a cutting-edge waste reduction strategy that is fairly costly but would be justified if it were paired with sending our trash to landfill. With more material removed and recycled from the waste stream, less trash will need to be shipped to landfills, lowering costs for the County. Paired with incineration, however, it is hard to justify financially. An enormous investment will have already been made to the upgrades to the incinerator and because the majority of incinerator costs are fixed, there is little financial benefit to reducing our waste. Overall, when the costs are calculated, this will be a very difficult strategy to justify. In 2027 the Council will have to approve this budget or choose an alternative.
A different plan might well be proposed. Next month we will have a new County Executive, Will Jawando, and a new Council President, Marilyn Balcombe, both of whom voted to end incineration.
Mr. Jawando has informed SCA and other environmental advocates that he is concerned about the feasibility of this resolution and would like to explore all options to find the most economically and environmentally sound solution. In her role as Council President, we expect that Marilyn Balcombe will also be a strong supporter of finding a more workable plan.
This recent vote is a setback, but the serious concerns with trying to keep incinerating are not going away. Moving forward, we will have sound leadership at the County level with whom to work.
Our efforts to close the incinerator, Montgomery County’s largest industrial polluter, will continue.
View the County Council session discussion and vote here.
Read more about the County Council session here.